In our seminar this week, there was a lot of dispute about
Jefferson’s document, Stanton’s argument, and Douglass’s speech. I don’t
believe that there is any one document that is the most correct and should be
the most respected. But since the Declaration of Independence got the most
hate, I will do my best to defend it. First of all, Jefferson’s main purpose in
creating the Declaration of Independence is to help the United States get out
of the tyrannical rule of the kind in Great Britain, not to make all American
citizens have all equal rights in regards to skin color or gender. He does say "that all men are created equal, and that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness", but this means
that no one person should have unlimited power over a body of people, such as
the king. In a way, he did help everybody become equal by getting rid of the tyrant.
I guess Stanton and Douglass thought that this would resolve all inequality
everywhere. They have to understand, though, that this document is because the
United States should be “Free and Independent States…Absolved from all
Allegiance to the British Crown”. That is the purpose of this document. Stanton
says that “He has compelled her to submit to laws, in the formation of which
she has no voice”, but that can change. If the Declaration of Independence had
not been created, women would have fewer rights in this tyranny, and a more
difficult chance to change the government, as the government was ruled
overseas. Furthermore, Douglass should not be degrading the Fourth of July. He
said so himself that “The signers of the Declaration of Independence were brave
men”, and that event was a very huge turning point in American history. Yes,
this does seem unfair for slaves, as they are still not quite free, but they
are one step closer to getting their rights with a more fair democratic
government. So don’t hate on Jefferson, because he made everybody’s lives much
easier by helping us separate from Great Britain.
Jenny, I agree with everything you said! The seminar seemed more like a debate. Debating for the Jefferson side, I felt like I was attacked by the two other sides for the document's hypocrisy, but all Jefferson tried to do was help the nation as a whole gain independence.
ReplyDeleteI really like how you used textual evidence from the three pieces to support Jefferson! Your point is very and makes sense because Jefferson was trying to do the better good for the whole nation.
ReplyDelete